AppealDesk vs Home Tax Shield: Which Is Right for You?

Last updated: February 16, 2026

Quick Verdict

AppealDesk is the better choice for lower cost ($49 vs ~30% of savings) and nationwide coverage. Home Tax Shield is better if you're in Texas and want a full-service company with AI-powered analysis and local representation at your hearing.

Best for budget-conscious DIY

AppealDesk — Homeowners who want professional evidence at a fraction of the percentage-based cost

Best for hands-off service

Home Tax Shield — Texas homeowners who want full-service representation with tech-forward approach

Rob Hartley·Updated February 16, 2026

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	AppealDesk	Home Tax Shield
Pricing	$49 flat fee	~30% of savings
Pricing model	Pay once, keep 100% of savings	Contingency — no savings, no fee
Coverage	All 50 states, 3,100+ counties	Texas only
Service type	DIY with professional evidence packet	Full-service (they handle everything)
What you receive	Evidence packet, filing guide, cover letter	They handle protest and hearing for you
Turnaround	Instant (minutes after purchase)	Follows county protest calendar
Technology	AI-powered comparable sales analysis	AI + data science with local professionals
Assessment ratio analysis	Included	Part of internal analysis (not customer-facing)
Who does the filing	You (with step-by-step instructions)	They file and attend hearing for you
Community reputation	Newer service	Strong positive reviews on Reddit (r/Austin, r/Houston)

Pricing & Total Cost

AppealDesk charges a flat $49 for your evidence packet, filing guide, and cover letter. Home Tax Shield charges approximately 30% of your first year's savings. On a typical Texas property tax reduction of $2,000-3,000 per year, Home Tax Shield's fee is $600-900 versus AppealDesk's $49. Home Tax Shield is refreshingly honest about typical outcomes: they cite a 3-5% average reduction. On a $400,000 home assessed at $420,000, a 5% reduction saves about $500-700 in taxes. At 30% contingency, that's $150-210 to Home Tax Shield. At a flat $49, AppealDesk saves you $100-160 more. The gap widens on higher-value properties where reductions are larger.

Coverage & Availability

Home Tax Shield serves Texas exclusively — they're a Texas-focused company through and through. If you live in any other state, they can't help you. AppealDesk covers all 50 states and over 3,100 counties, including every Texas county. For Texas homeowners, both services are available. For the other 49 states, AppealDesk is the option. Within Texas, Home Tax Shield has particularly strong community reputation in the Austin and Houston metro areas based on Reddit discussions.

Technology & Approach

Both services use technology to analyze property data, but they apply it differently. Home Tax Shield feeds AI and data science tools to their local, licensed tax professionals who then represent you at hearings. It's a tech-enhanced human service. AppealDesk uses AI-powered comparable sales analysis to generate your evidence packet directly — you receive the output in minutes. Home Tax Shield's approach means a human expert reviews your case and adjusts strategy for your specific county and hearing panel. AppealDesk's approach gives you the evidence to present yourself, with county-specific guidance on what works.

The Filing Experience

With Home Tax Shield, you sign up and they handle everything: filing the protest, preparing evidence, attending the informal hearing, and representing you at the ARB if needed. Your time investment is essentially zero after signup. With AppealDesk, you receive your evidence packet instantly, then follow the filing guide to submit your protest — usually through your county appraisal district's online portal. Most Texas filings take 10-15 minutes. If you need an informal hearing, you attend it yourself with your evidence packet and talking-point scripts. The question is whether those 10-15 minutes of filing are worth saving hundreds in fees.

Community Reputation

Home Tax Shield has earned notably positive reviews in Texas Reddit communities. Users in r/Austin and r/Houston report good experiences with the service and satisfactory outcomes. They're frequently mentioned alongside Ownwell and Five Stone Tax as a reputable Texas protest option. Home Tax Shield also differentiates itself by being transparent about realistic expectations — their 3-5% average reduction claim is more honest than companies promising dramatic savings. AppealDesk is newer to the market but offers a fundamentally different value proposition: professional evidence at a fraction of the cost.

Who Should Choose Home Tax Shield Instead

Choose Home Tax Shield if you're in Texas and want a full-service experience with zero effort on your part. Their combination of AI-powered analysis and experienced local professionals means your case gets technology-driven evidence presented by a human who knows your county's appraisal district. They're especially strong if you value community-proven reputation and honest expectations about outcomes. If your expected savings are small (under $165), their contingency model also has the advantage — you pay nothing if they don't save you money, whereas AppealDesk's $49 is paid upfront.

Check Your Property Now

See your estimated overassessment in minutes.

✓ All 50 states✓ Instant results✓ $49 flat fee

Not sure which option is right for you?

Try our free savings calculator to check if you're overassessed before deciding. It only takes a few seconds.

Ready to move forward? Our step-by-step appeal checklist walks you through every step of the filing process.

Home Tax Shield — Strengths & Weaknesses

Strengths

+Combines AI/data science technology with licensed, experienced local tax professionals
+Full-service — they handle the entire protest process including hearing representation
+Transparent about realistic outcomes (3-5% average reduction) rather than inflated claims
+Strong reputation in Texas Reddit communities (r/Austin, r/Houston) with positive user experiences

Weaknesses

–Texas only — no coverage in any other state
–Percentage-based fee (~30% of savings) costs significantly more than a flat $49 on most reductions
–No DIY or educational component — you don't see the evidence or learn the process
–Average 3-5% reduction means the fee may not be worth it on lower-value homes

Related Resources

Explore by Location

Texas Harris County, Texas Travis County, Texas Dallas County, Texas Tarrant County, Texas Williamson County, Texas

Read our complete guide to property tax appeals →

Ready to See If You're Overpaying?

Enter your address to see your estimated overassessment and potential savings.

✓ All 50 states✓ Instant results✓ $49 flat fee

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does Home Tax Shield charge?

Home Tax Shield uses contingency pricing at approximately 30% of your first year's savings. You pay nothing if they don't reduce your assessment. AppealDesk charges a flat $49 regardless of savings.

Does Home Tax Shield work outside Texas?

No. Home Tax Shield is a Texas-only service. AppealDesk covers all 50 states and 3,100+ counties.

Is Home Tax Shield better than Ownwell?

Both are full-service Texas options. Home Tax Shield has strong Reddit reviews and is transparent about realistic 3-5% reductions. Ownwell has broader coverage (9 states) and claims higher average savings. AppealDesk costs less than both at $49 flat.

Does Home Tax Shield attend the hearing for me?

Yes. Home Tax Shield handles the entire protest process including informal hearings and ARB representation. With AppealDesk, you attend hearings yourself using the evidence packet and scripts provided.

Which Texas protest service is cheapest?

AppealDesk at $49 flat is the least expensive option that provides professional evidence. DIY is free but requires 15-40 hours of research. Home Tax Shield and Ownwell charge percentages of savings.

Looking at other options beyond Home Tax Shield? See the best Home Tax Shield alternatives →